Idaho Supreme Court February 12, 1948, No. 7389. (White Earth Products Co. v. Idaho First Nat. Bank)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-02-1948

GIVENS, Chief Justice.

The filing of an original complaint and successive sustained demurrers and motions to strike and amended complaints, culminated in a third amended complaint, to which a motion to strike one paragraph thereof, was sustained. The general demurrer of respondents Crookhams was not sustained, but the special demurrers of all respondents for ambiguity, uncertainty, and unintelligibility were sustained, and upon appellant’s expressed declination to plead further, the court refrained from ruling on a motion to separately state, and entered judgment of dismissal — hence the appeal.

Appellant’s contention is evidently to the effect that if the complaint states some cause of action and a general demurrer challenging it on that ground is not sustained, judgment of dismissal may not be entered upon an order sustaining demurrers for ambiguity, uncertainty and unintelligibility. Though it is somewhat anomalous, appellant does not argue the complaint was not deficient in the particulars questioned by the special demurrers. It would thus appear the sole issue before us is as thus expressed by respondent Bank:

“It does not discuss the merits of the demurrer or motion, but rests its appeal solely upon the proposition that the order of dismissal was erroneous

because its third amended complaint states a cause of action.

Thus is presented for decision here the question of the Court’s power to dismiss the action. The question does not involve the right of appellant to file a fourth amended complaint. Appellant did not ask permission to amend, but elected to stand upon the third amended complaint.”

Section 5-607, I.C.A., enumerates seven distinct grounds of demurrer, the seventh being—

“That the complaint is ambiguous, unintelligible or uncertain.”

Such ground is not comprehended within a general demurrer. Palmer v. Utah etc. Ry. Co., 2 Idaho (Hash.) 315, at page 975, 318, 13 P. 425.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.