Supreme Court of Missouri September 13, 1948, No. 40528. (Cook v. Kansas City)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-09-1948

*299

[431]

BARRETT, C.

This is an action for damages for injuries to the plaintiffs’ residence. The injuries are alleged to have been caused by blasting. The jury, by a nine to three verdict, found for the plaintiffs and assessed their damages at $25,000. The trial court reduced the verdict to $10,000 and the city appeals.

[432] The controversy arose out of the construction in 1938 to 1939 of a W. P. A. sponsored sewer on State Line Road. Kansas City sponsored the project, furnishing the materials and supplies, including dynamite and certain professional services and W. P. A. furnished the labor. The proposal and request for the project were signed by the Assistant Director of Public Works at the request of the Director of Public Works who was also the W. P. A. director for the State of Missouri. The original arrangément for the project was made by the then City Manager. The city’s sewer engineer furnished the “elevation limits” and located the places manholes were to be dug, The blasting occurred in the process of sinking the manholes through shale and rock. It was not only admitted that the city complied with its part of the arrangement and furnished the materials but it was also admitted that the city •officials' had knowledge of the blasting. There was no written contract, no declaration of necessity, no publication and public hearing, no perfection and adoption of plans and specifications, no calling for bids or award to the lowest bidder and no ordinance confirming the contract in accordance with the provisions of the city charter and, therefore, it is urged that the action of the city in building the sewer was ultra vires and void. The action of the council being ultra vires, it is argued that the city is not liable for the tort and that the court erred in not directing a verdict for the city.

There can be no doubt concerning the general rules and there is no disposition now to modify them. Municipalities, whether reasonably or unreasonably (3 Mo. L. R.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.