Supreme Court of New Hampshire July 6, 1948, No. 3733. (Plante v. Wendell)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-07-1948
Kenison, J.
The pivotal issue in this proceeding is the ruling of the trial court that “whatever the O. P. A. regulations may be, the state court is not controlled by them.” The Emergency Price Control Act of 1942 (50 U. S. C. A. App. s. 901
et
seq), as amended, has been held to be constitutionally valid as applied not only to private owners
(Yakus
v.
United States,
321 U. S. 414;
Bowles
v.
Willingham,
321 U. S. 503) but also to a state which sells timber from its school lands.
Case
v.
Bowles,
327 U. S. 92. At the time this case was considered by the Trial Judge he may have relied on
Testa
v.
Katt,
71 R. I. 472, in making his ruling. Subsequently, however, the case was reversed by the United States Supreme Court in
Testa
v.
Katt,
330 U. S. 386, where it decided that a state court was precluded by the supremacy clause of the Federal Constitution from declining to enforce the act and the regulations issued thereunder. That case is binding on the parties to the litigation and all courts in the state.
The precise question in this proceeding has not been decided in the cases cited. Here the defendant claims as a defense that the price per thousand for the logs exceeded the ceiling price under the applicable regulation. Maximum Price Regulation No. 533-5 effective May 15, 1944; 9 Federal Register 5238. The plaintiff denies the materiality of the regulation but in any event claims the transaction comes within an exception therein as a sale of an entire business. While there is not much authority in point it is now apparent that the regulation is material and the facts of the case should be decided in order to determine its applicability. See Sleigh, Violation of O. P. A. Regulations as Defense in Contract Action, 28 B. U. Law Rev. 22 (1948).
The consideration stated in the deed from the plaintiff to the defendant was “one and more dollars.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit