Supreme Court of South Carolina April 5, 1948, 16063 (Pennell & Harley, Inc. v. Harris)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-04-1948

Baker, C.J.:

This is an appeal from an Order of Honorable T. S. Sease dated December 11, 1947, affirming a taxation of appeal costs by the Honorable E. W. Miller, Clerk of Court of Common Pleas, made in the above styled case.

In the main case, in which the appellant here was the respondent, the decision of tjie lower Court was confirmed by the Supreme Court in all particulars with a single exception. See

Pennell & Harley, Inc. v. Harris et al.,

210 S. C. 504, 43 S. E. (2d) 490, 496. The opinion of this Court used the following language: “It is lastly contended that the Court erred in awarding a deficiency or personal judgment against appellants for the amount due on the two notes and mortgages foreclosed. Respondent stated he is agreeable to the decree being modified so as to relieve appellants from any liability for a deficiency judgment. It is accordingly so modified”.

It is contended by respondents here that' this . language constitutes such a modification of the Circuit decree as to-entitle them to tax their appeal costs, and it was so held below, first by the Clerk of the Common Pleas Court and later by the Circuit Judge.

*211

The concluding paragraphs of the complaint in both causes of action alleged in the foreclosure proceeding are identical, and read as follows: “That the plaintiff herein hereby specifically waives any deficiency judgment and asks that the sale of the property shall be a final sale”.

In the main case, and during the pendency of the action, John W. Harris, Jr., acquired the interest of Pennell & Harley, Inc., and an order was passed dismissing it as a party plaintiff, and directing that the action be continued for the purpose of adjudicating the issues raised between John W. Harris, Jr., and his sisters and the heirs of a deceased brother. “The effect of this order was to substitute John W. Harris, Jr., as plaintiff in said foreclosure proceedings”. See

Pennell & Harley, Inc., v. Harris et al., supra.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.