Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas May 19, 1948, No. 24019. (Adams v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-05-1948

BEAUCHAMP, Judge.

The appeal is from a conviction for cattle theft with a punishment of two years in the penitentiary.

The indictment alleges the theft of two head of cattle from W. B. Walker and Alonzo Love, alleged to be the corporeal personal property of W. B. Walker and Alonzo Love without the consent of the said W. B. Walker and Alonzo Love and with intent to deprive the said W. W. Walker and Alonzo Love of the value of same.

In the trial of the case the State failed to prove that the

*26

property was taken without the consent of Walker but confined it to proving that it was done without the knowledge and consent of Alonzo Love. Mr. Walker was present in the court house during the trial and available to the court.

Touching the issue thus raised, the State’s Attorney before this Court said in his brief:

“In our very humble opinion, the most serious question presented in this record relates to the fact that the State, having alleged ownership of the cattle to be jointly in W. B. Walker and Alonzo Love, that the burden therefore was upon the State to prove such allegation, if it could. This record affirmatively reflects that Walker was not subpoenaed as a witness but was present in court, sworn with the other witnesses, placed under the rule, and remained in attendance upon court throughout the trial but the State wholly failed to call Walker as a witness.

“In Mr. Branch’s Annotated Penal Code, Sec. 2440, he states: ‘The allegation of ownership of the alleged stolen property, being descriptive and essential, must be proved as laid,’ citing

many

authorities; and, again, under the same section it is stated, ‘Joint ownereship, if alleged, must be proved as laid,’ citing authorities; and, again, under the same section, ‘If ownership is alleged to be in more than one person, the proof must correspond with the allegation.’

“In Section 2448, Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.