Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit March 12, 1948, No. 12108 (Allen v. Knott)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-03-1948
McCORD, Circuit Judge.
This appeal contests the validity of an alleged deficiency in federal income taxes and interest in the sum of $3,970.15, assessed against and paid by the taxpayer, James A. Knott, for the years 1939, 1940 and 1941.
The question presented is whether a valid partnership for income tax purposes existed between the taxpayer and his wife for the tax years in question. The case was tried to a jury which determined this issue in favor of the taxpayer, and the Collector prosecutes this appeal.
The evidence shows that the G. A. B. School of Commerce, at Macon, Georgia, has been operated since the year 1939 by the taxpayer and his wife, Emily Dozier Knott, as a purported partnership, and that individual returns under the alleged partnership have been filed since that year. The G. A. B. School of Commerce is an institution approximately fifty years of age. For several years prior to 1937, it was operated as a corporation. During that year it was operated as partnership between taxpayer and one R. L. Wilson. Mr. Wilson died in January, 1938, and for a short while afterwards the school continued to be operated as a partnership with Mrs. Wilson acting as partner in her husband’s stead. However, in April, 1938, taxpayer purchased the Wilson interest, and for the next year operated the school as sole owner. During this period taxpayer gave his wife a one-half interest in the school, and in April, 1939, they signed a partnership agreement providing that Mr. Knott would devote his entire time and efforts to the business and his wife should devote only such time as appeared to the best interests-thereof, but that she would assist in any financial and credit arrangements that from-time to time might become essential. The agreement further provided for the payment of salaries to the parties in proportion to their respective efforts-, and that the profits would be divided equally between them.
After the death of Mr.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit