Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) November 1, 1949 (Stevens v. Coleman)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-11-1949
Judge Helm
Affirming.
Appellant, Evelyn Jarvis, and appellee, Harold
*315
Coleman, were candidates for the Republican nomination for County Court Clerk of Carter County. The tabulation of the election commissioners — W. E. Stevens, T. H. Holbrook, and G-. H. Templeton — named as appellants here, showed 1659 votes for appellee, Coleman, and 1659 votes for appellant, Jarvis.
Appellant filed a “petition requesting recount of ballots.” The regular judge having disqualified, by agreement of the parties Honorable A. W. Mann was selected as special judge. Upon the recount, Judge Mann found “and adjudged * * * that the plaintiff, Harold Coleman, received a majority of nine votes over the defendant, Evelyn Jarvis, and that he is entitled to the nomination by the Republican party for the office of County Court Clerk of Carter County.” The election commissioners were directed to reassemble and issue to Coleman a certificate of nomination. Mrs. Jarvis, appellant, prosecutes this appeal.
Appellee moves to dismiss the appeal because: (1) The statement of appeal does not designate the date on which the judgment was rendered; (2) appellant has failed to file in this court any sufficient supersedeas bond; and (3) the election commissioners are not proper parties here.
The statement of appeal shows: “The parties to this appeal are as above captioned. The judgment appealed from was rendered by the Carter Circuit Court on Page 22 of the record.” The election commissioners are not necessary or proper parties here, but Evelyn Jarvis, the appellant, is named in the caption of the statement of appeal as an appellant. "While the commissioners should not have been named as appellants, the fact that they were is not ground for dismissing the appeal.
The date of the judgment is not set out in the statement of appeal, but by turning to Page 22 of the record, we find the judgment of the trial court and that it was entered on September 1,1949.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit