Court of Appeals of Tennessee January 27, 1949 (Alston v. Porter)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-01-1949

HOWELL, J.

The original bill in this case was filed by the complainants Mrs. Addie Alston and Mrs. Lelia Dee against Mrs. Anderson Porter, Jr. and alleged that an error had been made in the office of a firm of Nashville lawyers in the writing of deed to some property in Davidson Connty in that the deed as written contained descriptions of two small tracts of land when as a matter of fact only, one tract was contracted for and purchased by the defendant. The bill prayed that this mistake be corrected and that all right, title, claim and interest vested in the defendant by this erroneous deed be divested out of her and vested in the complainants or that the deed be reformed so as to convey only the land purchased by the defendant. The defendant answered this bill and disclosed that after the execution of the deed as set out in this bill, she had conveyed the property in question to Mrs. Florence Gupton and Mrs. Chloe B. Brown. She denied that there was any error in the description in the deed or that any mistake had been made. The complainants then filed an Amended and Supplemental bill to which they made Mrs. Gupton and Mrs. Brown defendants and renewed the prayer that the title to the land, included in this deed by mistake be divested out of the defendants and vested in them. An answer was filed to this amended and supplemental bill denying the material allegations thereof.

Upon the hearing, the Chancellor found that “the record established by a clear preponderance of the evidence, that

*630

the deed in question included tracts Nos. 1 and 2, whereas, the agreement and understanding of the parties was for the purchase of tract No. 2, for a consideration of $1200.00.

“Thus, the inclusion of tract No. 1 in the description written in the deed, was an inadvertence and mistake, and complainant is entitled to have same corrected by decree of this Court.

“To refuse a decree of correction would be inequitable and unconscionable.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.