Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit February 1, 1949, No. 12454 (Fidelity & Casualty Co. v. Herod)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-02-1949

SIBLEY, Circuit Judge.

Curtis Herod obtained against Talmadge Ivy a judgment for $5,000 damages for a personal injury inflicted on Aug. 25, 1946, by Ivy in the operation °of a certain automobile. Herod, on return of nulla bona, sued Fidelity and Casualty Company on a policy of insurance by which the latter promised to pay on behalf of Ivy all sums which Ivy should become obligated to pay by reason of liability imposed by law for bodily injury caused by accident arising out of the ownership or use of the automobile. The Company’s answer admitted the-accident on Aug. 25, 1946, and the recovery of the judgment against Ivy, and that it had issued the policy to Ivy on March 6, 1946, for the period of a year, but alleged that by its terms Ivy had the right to cancel the policy and had on Aug. 20, 1946,, done so, delivering it to the local agent at *970Oxford, Mississippi, who had issued it, for cancellation and return of the unearned premium; that the agent indorsed the cancellation on the policy on Aug. 20, and forwarded it to the Company and it was not of force on Aug. 25. Other details are not material to our decision.

On a trial the Court found the policy was in force on Aug. 25, referring especially to the entries on the policy produced by the Company, and gave judgment on it. The Company appeals.

The policy, according to the evidence, was required to be obtained and carried by Ivy on his obtaining a permit to operate the automobile as a taxicab within the city limits of Oxford, the ordinance requiring it to be deposited with the City Clerk, and the policy containing a rider: “It is hereby understood and agreed that the Company will give notice to the City of Oxford, Mississippi, at least ten days prior to their cancellation of this policy.” The City revoked Ivy’s permit and took up his badge, which he had to wear in the city, on Aug. 12.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.