District Court, E.D. New York February 25, 1949, No. A-17048 (Lynch v. The Edward S. Atwood)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-02-1949
BYERS, District Judge.
This is a scow damage cause in which it must be deemed to have been shown that libellant’s wooden scow Seaboard No. 20 was squeezed between the derrick Comrade and the north side of Pier 36 N.R. on January 13, 1944, at approximately 5:45 P.M., Eastern War Time.
Puzzling questions of both fact and law are presented by the pleadings and the evidence. *
The scow sank, decks to, at Pier 34, about an hour or less after she had been towed from the slip between Piers 37 and 36, as the result of taking water through bottom planks which had been started away from her bilge log, on the starboard side in the vicinity of bays 3, 4 and 5.
The scow had carried two airplanes and two boxes (containing wing assemblies) from Port Newark to Pier 40 N.R. on January 12, 1944, and was handled thereafter' by the claimant-respondent’s tug Edward S. Atwood on the morning of the next day; that is, she was towed from Pier 40 to a berth in the slip between Piers 37 and 36 and placed near the bulkhead on the north side of Pier 36, awaiting discharge.
To accomplish that, she was hauled into position alongside the derrick Comrade, at a little after 5 :00 P.M., E.W.T., the latter being held by lines alongside the tanker Abiqua, which lay bow in on the south side of Pier 37.
The slip is 150 feet wide, and when all vessels were in the position stated, their combined widths were: (Abiqua 68.2 feet overall; Comrade 34.9 feet, and Seaboard No. 20 34.5 feet) 137.6 feet.
This left an apparent margin of about 12 feet to accommodate the spaces necessarily present between all vessels and both Piers.
The space on the port side of the Abiqua would be affected by tidal movement, and perhaps by the northwest wind which prevailed, of from 25 to 34 miles an hour.
When the Seaboard No. 20 was landed alongside the Comrade, the testimony is ■ that there was from 3 to 4 feet of open water between her and Pier 36.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit