Washington Supreme Court November 16, 1950, 31389 (State v. Conklin)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-11-1950

Mallery, J.

The defendant was convicted of the crime of taking indecent liberties on the person of his stepdaughter, who was under the age of fifteen years. He appeals.

The appellant concedes the sufficiency of the evidence to take the case to the jury. He contends the trial court erred

*390

in admitting the testimony of the complaining witness that she had made a prior out-of-court complaint as to the offense charged, upon the ground that the testimony, identified the appellant as being the offender. Appellant contends this was reversible error under the rule of

State v. Murley,

35 Wn. (2d) 233, 212 P. (2d) 801.

The testimony objected to is as follows:

“Q. Will you state, Brita, whether or not on or about October 3rd, 1949, you appeared at a juvenile court hearing regarding matters of your custody? A. Yes. Q. Who was there on that day? A. Judge Long, my stepfather, Miss Swanson, and you were, — and I don’t know who else. Q. Were some other people in the room? A. Yes. Q. Mr. Conk-lin was there? A. Yes. Q. Did you, Brita, at any time while you were there at the juvenile court make a complaint against your stepfather regarding the conduct which he had had toward you? A. Yes. Mr. Soderland: Object to that question. Such a complaint would not in any sense be a timely complaint unless it is shown to come within the rule of hue and cry in orbit of human experience. The foundation has not been laid. The Court: She has answered yes and the answer may stand. Mr. Soderland: Exception. Q. Brita, what conduct did you complain about as to your stepfather? Mr. Soderland: Object to that. I think the testimony should be as to what this witness can testify to at the present time. The Court: I think the point is well taken. Miss Mechem: I think it is proper. Q. Brita, at any time during the time you lived out there in the Duwamish area will you state whether or not the defendant, Wilbur Conklin acted in a way toward you which you considered improper?”

.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.