Supreme Court of New Jersey June 27, 1950 (Stretch v. Watson)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-06-1950

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Heher, J.

The primary question here concerns the legal effect of the alteration by defendant Yerna Stretch of a deed of conveyance of farm lands at Shiloh in Stow Creek Township, Cumberland County, New Jersey, made and delivered May 22, 1941, by defendant Mary J. Watson to Verna Stretch and her husband, the plaintiff, by the substitution of defendant Adah B. Sox as the. grantee. The altered deed was recorded January 15, 1943. A deed purporting to convey the lands to defendant Wallace A. Halter was made and delivered by Sox on February 13, 1943, and recorded two days thereafter. The Chancery Division of the Superior Court dismissed a bill of complaint addressed by plaintiff to the old

*273

Court of Chancery alleging that the alteration of the Watson deed was designed to defraud him of “his right, title and interest” in the lands as a tenant by the entirety, and that Halter Cihad full knowledge of the fraud” and had the same fraudulent intent, and praying that both conveyances be decreed void and that the lands be reeonveyed “to the respective parties * * * found to be entitled thereto.” An appeal from the judgment of dismissal taken by Halter and his wife, Ida, to the Appellate Division of the Superior Court was, before hearing, certified here on our own motion.

The Superior Court concluded that the alteration “avoided the deed.” The principle invoked was that an alteration of this character “by one of two grantees named in a deed, unauthorized by the second grantee, serves to avoid it.” It was found that the conveyance to the Stretches was in trust for their minor children, Mary Ellen and Thomas, Jr., but that, while it failed as an express trust for want of the manifestation in writing required by

B. S.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.