Louisiana Court of Appeal January 31, 1950, 3185 (Girouard v. Agate)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-01-1950

44 So.2d 388 (1950) GIROUARD et al. v. AGATE. No. 3185. Court of Appeal of Louisiana, First Circuit. January 31, 1950. A. Wilmot Dalferes, Lafayette, for appellants. *389 Mouton & Mouton, Lafayette, for appellee. ELLIS, Judge. The plaintiffs in the main suit are seeking damages because of injuries received by their brother which caused his death when he allegedly fell through an elevator shaft in a building owned by the defendant Agate and under lease to Bernard LeBlanc, who in turn had subleased the upper floor of the building to Parkerson-Dupuis, Inc. for a temporary office. By way of answer to the suit the defendant prayed that Bernard LeBlanc be called in warranty to defend the suit and for judgment against him for whatever amount be rendered against the defendant. To this call in warranty Bernard LeBlanc filed an exception of no cause or right of action. On the exception of no right of action evidence was taken, and after due hearing the trial court rendered judgment maintaining the exceptions of no right and of no cause of action to the call in warranty. From this adverse ruling, the defendant has taken this appeal. Both counsel have filed quite extensive briefs, however, the defendant is basing his call in warranty upon an alleged violation by LeBlanc of the provisions of Articles 2710 and 2711 of the Civil Code. To put it as stated in defendant's brief, this case "involves a failure of the lessee to carry out the obligations under the plain terms and conditions of Articles 2710 and 2711, C. C." He does not contend that his call is based upon the Code of Practice, Articles 378 or 379. An examination of the contract of lease entered into between the defendant and Le Blanc fails to disclose any contract of warranty or any assumption of responsibility for the condition of the premises under the provisions of Act No. 174 of 1932.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.