Supreme Court of New Jersey January 9, 1950 (Protomastro v. BD. OF ADJUSTMENT OF CITY OF HOBOKEN)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-01-1950
The opinion of the court was delivered by
Case, J.
This appeal from a judgment of the Law Division of the Superior Court to the Appellate Division was certified to us on our own motion. It concerns a determination by the Board of Adjustment of the City of Hoboken granting a variance from the city zoning ordinance.
*497
The building inspector of the City of Hoboken rejected the application of Avenel Industrial Realty Corporation for a permit to erect a brick store building on property known as 817-825 Bloomfield Street and 816-820 Washington Street because the applicant proposed to build for, and utilize the structure as, a “super market” and the Bloomfield Street frontage was in an area zoned by ordinance for residences and against business erections and business uses. The matter then came before the Board of Adjustment on an appeal which was accorded the status of an application for a variance under
B. S.
40:55-39 (c). The board, after public hearing and against the protests and proofs of objectors, granted the variance. A writ of
certiorari
to review the decision was allowed by the former Supreme Court and heard after the change in the court system by the Appellate Division, which (1
N. J. Super.
102) set aside the resolution of the board because it did not contain a finding that “a literal enforcement of the provisions of the ordinance will result in unnecessary hardship,” citing
Brandon v.
Montclair, 124
N. J. L.
135
(Sup. Ct.
1940); affirmed, 125
Id.
367
(E.
&
A.
1940), and directed that the matter be remanded “for further action in accordance with this opinion.”
After the record had gone down, the board, on February 1, 1949, proceeded to hold a further hearing at which the attorneys for the parties were invited to attend and the objectors were permitted to present additional proof. Two days later, on February 3, 1949, with all members present and voting, the board voted two in favor of and three against a motion to grant the variance.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit