Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit January 9, 1950, 12784 (Mims v. Central Mfrs. Mut. Ins. Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-1950

RUSSELL, Circuit Judge.

Appellant, complainant in the trial Court, instituted four suits against four fire insurance companies to recover the face amount of four policies, aggregating $25,-000, for loss resulting from the destruction of a stock of merchandise she owned, located at Lafayette, Alabama. Jurisdiction was predicated upon diversity of citizenship and amount in controversy. The allegations of each of the complaints are the same, as are the defenses interposed.

The defenses denied the value of the merchandise was in the amount alleged, and asserted that the policies and their liability had been voided by reason of willful concealment and misrepresentation of material facts, as well as fraud and false swearing, all done with intent to deceive. The fifth defense is predicated upon the failure of the insured to comply with stated provisions of the policies.

1

The trial Court denied the motion to strike and this action is assigned as error.

The four cases were consolidated for trial, which was had to a jury, and a verdict returned in favor of the defendants. The only assignments of error upon the rulings during the course of the trial, by

*58

objections properly presented to the Court and preserved, relate to the rulings of the Court admitting into evidence numerous depositions. Appellant’s counsel moved to suppress the depositions, and that they be not admitted, upon the ground that the depositions were taken upon notice specifying times and conditions wholly unreasonably and oppressive. To understand the nature of this objection and to determine its validity, it is necessary to review some of the circumstances in detail. The complainant had opened her store carrying a stock of ladies’ merchandise and wearing apparel in February, 1947. The first policy of insurance was procured on February 19, 1947, in the amount of $10,000, and three cumulative policies were thereafter obtained, one on April 8, 1947, and the third and fourth on April 30, 1947.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.