Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit January 24, 1950, 12827 (Vahlsing v. Harrell)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-01-1950
HUTCHESON, Circuit Judge.
The suit was for a judgment declaring that plaintiff had a right to have and' maintain a suction pipe under, and to draw water therewith for irrigation from a drainage ditch on, defendant’s land.
The claim was: (1) that the drainage ditch was on defendant’s land
*623
under a valid easement granted the LaFeria Water Control and Improvement District, Cameron County No. 3, hereafter called “The District” by plaintiff’s predecessor in title; (2) that the drainage easement, included the right to construct, have, and maintain suction pipes across such easement and into said ditch for the removal therefrom of water for irrigation therefrom; and (3) that The District, having the right to permit appellant to maintain its suction pipe across the easement and into the drainage ditch, had given plaintiff permission to do so.
The defendant denied these claims and, in its turn, sought a judgment declaring: (1) that the District did not have, and, therefore, could not grant to plaintiff the right to construct, have, or maintain the disputed suction pipe without defendant’s consent; (2) that defendant was a bona fide purchaser, without notice of plaintiff’s alleged rights, and was not bound by them ; and (3) that plaintiff was estopped to deny defendant’s title to the land in question because plaintiff had in two leasing agreements upon valuable consideration recognized defendant’s superior title to such portion of land and the right to grant or withhold from plaintiff the right to maintain the suction pipe.
A jury having been demanded and allowed, the case proceeded to trial and the taking of evidence,
1
consisting mainly of agreed facts, concluded, both plaintiff and defendant moved for a directed verdict.
Plaintiff’s motion was based on the ground that the existence of the claimed
*624
easement and defendant’s-knowledge of it were established as matter of law, and a verdict for plaintiff on both issues was demanded.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit