Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit May 25, 1950, 10094_1 (In Re Industrial Sapphire Mfg. Co., Inc)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-05-1950
GOODRICH, Circuit Judge.
This appeal in bankruptcy is to determine the validity of a chattel mortgage. The question is raised by the mortgagee’s petition for leave to institute legal proceedings under the mortgage, which petition is opposed by the trustee. The Referee granted the petition; the District Court confirmed without opinion and the trustee appeals.
The bankrupt, Industrial Sapphire Manufacturing Co., Inc., executed the mortgage in New York on August 22, 1947. The subject-matter of the mortgage consisted of chattels then in New York. The present petitioner, Martha L. Haines, is the assignee of the original mortgagee. The property was subsequently moved to the new plant of the bankrupt company located
*590
in Quakertown, Pennsylvania. The petitioner knew of and consented to the removal. The mortgaged property is still in Quakertown in the possession of the corporation which succeeded .to the business of the bankrupt.
We think the simplest and most direct method of settling the validity of the mortgage is to approach it in the orthodox conflict of laws fashion. We look first to the New York transactions to see their effect under New York law. Restatement, Conflict of Laws § 265. See Personal Finance Company of New York v. General Finance Co., 1938, 133 Pa.Super. 582, 3 A.2d 174. The appellant attacks the validity of the New York transactions because, he says, the assignment of the mortgage to the petitioner was never recorded and that failure to record is fatal.
The New York statute provides in Section 232-a, New York Lien Law, Mck. Consol.Laws, c. 33: “Such assignment * * * shall be. filed,
prior to the filing of a satisfaction thereof,
in the same office or offices, where the original instrument or a copy or copies thereof were filed at the time of the execution of the same. [Italics ours.]”
It. will be noted that the statute calls for a filing of the assignment prior to the satisfaction of the mortgage.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit