Court of Customs and Patent Appeals June 30, 1950, Patent Appeals 5704 (Kvalnes v. Wright)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-06-1950

GARRETT, Chief Judge.

This is an appeal from the decision of the Board of Interference Examiners of the United States Patent Office awarding priority of invention to the party Wright. Four counts seem to have been involved before the board, but the appeal to us was taken only as to Count 1, which reads:

1. The disazo dye of the formula:

Wright (who describes himself as a British subject in his application) is the senior party. His application was filed June 25, 1942. The application of Kvalnes, which appears to be assigned to E. I. du Pont de Nemours & Company, was filed June 17, 1943.

The board awarded Wright constructive reduction to practice as of July 22, 1941, on which date a Provisional Specification of a British application was filed in his behalf. This award is not challenged before us.

In his preliminary statement Kvalnes alleged actual reduction to practice of the count before us “during the month of June 1939.”

The board held, in effect, that the compound of the count had been produced at the time claimed for reduction to practice, but held that the tests made of the compound were not sufficient to demonstrate its utility. Therefore, it was held that appellant could not be awarded actual reduction to practice but was confined to the constructive reduction to practice incident to his filing date of June 17, 1943.

We quote the following from the board’s decision (reference to page numbers of the

*194

record being omitted as indicated by asterisks) :

“Diazotization requires observance of definite conditions. Equimolecular quantities of nitrite and amine are used and the mineral acid should be in excess, at least 2 to

2^/i

equivalents being present.- Diazotization is always carried out in the cold. Diazonium salts couple readily and easily to phenols and aromatic amines under the proper procedure.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.