Court of Appeals of Maryland April 14, 1950, [No. 141, October Term, 1949.] (Duvall v. Lacy)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-04-1950

Marbury, C. J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

Appellants filed a petition for a writ of mandamus against the Comptroller of the State, alleging that he was about to remove the income tax division of his office from Annapolis to the City of Baltimore, in violation of Article VI, Section 1, of the Constitution of Maryland. They allege that the rental of office space for this division in Baltimore will constitute a diversion of public monies to an unlawful use, that there is now available ample space and adequate facilities for the division in the State Office Building in Annapolis, and if added space is wanted it can be obtained in that City. The Comptroller demurred, the lower court sustained the demurrer and dismissed the petition, and from its order petitioners appeal here.

The petitioners in the writ are the Mayor and Aider-men of the City of Annapolis, a municipal body corporate, and two individuals. The petition states that the corporation brings this suit on behalf of itself and of all citizens, residents, voters and taxpayers of the State, county and City. One of the individual petitioners is Frank M. Duvall, a citizen, resident, voter and taxpayer of the State and of Anne Arundel County, and he brings the suit as well on behalf of all others similarly situated. The other individual petitioner is the Mayor of Annapolis, who is also alleged to be a citizen, resident, voter and taxpayer of the State, county and City, and a merchant engaged in business in Annapolis, and he also brings the suit as well on behalf of all others similarly situated.

*143

Municipal corporations have only the powers conferred upon them by the Legislature, and these are to be strictly construed. “To doubt such power in a given case is to deny its existence.”

Hanlon v. Levin,

168 Md. 674, 179 A. 286, 287,

Mayor & City Council of City of Baltimore v. Canton Company,

186 Md. 618, 631, 47 A. 2d 775.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.