Connecticut Superior Court March 21, 1950, File 18468 (Whitman Hotel Corp. v. Elliott & Watrous Engineering Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-03-1950

COMLEY, J.

The defendants make the claim that there is no evidence that the damage to the plaintiff’s hotel building was caused by the blasting in the Shetucket River. It is true that the plaintiff has not offered proof that each and every crack in the walls was connected with a specific blast. It does appear, however, that from the early summer of 1947 until the commencement of this action, the defendants were engaged in. blasting operations of huge proportions which involved the cutting of a wasteway through solid rock, 750 feet long, 80 feet wide and 26 feet deep. About 23,000 cubic yards of ledge-rock were removed through the use of 53,000 pounds of 60 per cent high velocity gelatin. The scene of these operations was at its nearest point only 230 feet from the plaintiff’s building. At each blast six holes filled with dynamite to a depth of at least

*488

twelve feet were exploded. The defendants offered evidence that .there was other blasting in Norwich during the period in ques- . tion; most of it connected with the construction of sewers. Compared with the operations of the defendants in the Shetucket River this other blasting was trivial and negligible. In the very nature of things it would be virtually impossible for the plaintiff to connect each item of damage with a specific blast. It would be highly unrealistic to hold the plaintiff to that degree of proof. All the circumstances of the case, including the nature of the defendants’ work and its enormous size and extent, the location of the plaintiff’s building and the kind of damage which appeared in the building during the period of blasting, lead irresistibly to the conclusion that it was the acts of the de' fendants which caused the damage.

The most serious question in the case is whether the plain' tiff has the burden of proving that the defendants were negli' gent in the conduct of their work. The complaint is drawn upon two theories.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.