Alabama Court of Appeals May 9, 1950, 6 Div. 999 (Karrh v. Brown)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-05-1950
CARR, Judge.
This is a suit for property damages incident to a collision between two automobiles.
Without dispute in the evidence one of the cars was the property of Tommie Karrh, the defendant below. At the time of the collision it was being driven by his wife.
In the court below there was a judgment in favor of the plaintiff.
The only question presented for our review is whether or not Mrs. Karrh was the agent of her husband within the purview of the applicable rule.
The proof of ownership in Mr. Karrh raised the administrative presumption that Mrs. Karrh was his agent and she was acting at the time of the collision in the line and scope of such agency. This was merely a prima facie presumption, based on the fairness of imposing on the defendant the burden of proving that the driver was not his agent, or, if so, she was not at the time acting in the line and scope of the agency relationship.
In this state of the record: “If the evidence thereon is in conflict, or leads to doubtful inference only, the issue should go to the jury. If, however, the evidence, without dispute, rebuts the facts thus presumed, there is no issue for the jury, and the general affirmative charge should be *310given for the defendant on request.” Tullis v. Blue, 216 Ala. 577, 114 So. 185, 187.
See also, Cruse-Crawford Mfg. Co. v. Rucker, 220 Ala. 101, 123 So. 897; Perfection Mattress & Spring Co. v. Windham, 236 Ala. 239, 182 So. 6; Alabama Electric Coop. v. Free, 34 Ala.App. 425, 40 So.2d 632.
At common law it was the general rule that a husband was civilly liable for the torts of his wife committed 'by her during coverture. In most jurisdictions this doctrine is no longer followed. By statute, in .this State, it is provided that the husband shall not 'be liable for a tort of his wife in the commission of which he does not participate. Title 34, Sec. 70, Code 1940.
We do not adhere to the “family purpose” doctrine in this jurisdiction.
In the case of Tullis v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit