Court of Appeals of Kentucky November 10, 1950 (Williams v. Commonwealth)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-11-1950
Judge Rees
Reversing.
John Williams was convicted of the crime of grand larceny, and his punishment fixed by the jury at confinement in the state reformatory for a term of two years. The court overruled the defendant’s motion for a new trial, but later entered a judgment reducing the sentence to one year in the state reformatory. Grounds urged for reversal of the judgment are: (1) Variance between the proof and the indictment; (2) failure of the trial court to give an instruction on petit larceny; and (3) insufficiency of the evidence.
The indictment charged that the accused in Floyd County on the 4th day of January, 1950, and before the finding of the indictment, did “unlawfully and feloniously take,' steal ánd carry away one overcoat, two pairs of shoes and two pairs of pants of the value of more than twenty dollars, the personal property of Inland Steel Company with the felonious and fraudulent intent then and there to convert the same to his own use, and to permanently deprive the said Inland Steel Company of its property therein.” The evidence appears in the bill of exceptions in narrative form.
John W. Rupe, manager of the department store at Wheelwright, Kentucky, owned by the Inland Steel Company, testified that he first learned that articles were missing from the store when two pairs of pants were returned to him one evening in December, 1949, by either John Williams or one Robert Moseby; that thereafter he received information that a pair of shoes belonging to the store was at the home of Robert Moseby; and that he sent J. D. Lewis, janitor at the store, to the Moseby home, and that Lewis returned to the store with one pair of shoes which sold for $19.95. He further stated that Williams was in and around the store at or about the time the pants were returned. J. D. Lewis testified that he went to the home of Robert Moseby and obtained a pair of shoes which he gave to *35Mr. Rupe at the store.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit