Court of Appeals of Kentucky December 1, 1950 (Funk v. Whitaker)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-12-1950
Judge Latimer
Affirming.
*205Appellee, Roy Whitaker, filed this action January 14, 1947, to enjoin appellant, Charley Funk, from using a disputed road or passway across appellee’s land. Appellant, by answer, denied the allegations of the petition and plead affirmatively that the disputed road is a public road and had been used as such for more than sixty years prior to the institution of this action. Appellant also alleged, in substance, that the road was necessary as a means of access to and from his farm. The Chancellor gave judgment as prayed by appellee, from which this appeal is taken.
Appellant apparently relies for reversal on the theory that the evidence will not support the judgment.
The parties own adjoining tracts of land. The evidence clearly shows that up to 1914 there was a road of some type passing across appellee’s land at the approximate location of the road in dispute. Several witnesses stated that the old road was a “haul” road. In any event, in 1914 appellee and Damon Karr, the then owner of appellant’s tract, jointly erected a rail fence across the then existing road. Damon Karr so testified. He also testified that no gate or bars were left in this fence. Mr. and Mrs. Wells, who owned appellant’s land from 1919 to 1933, testified the fence remained there throughout their period of occupancy. Mrs. Wells said that there was no road through there and that they planted corn up to the fence. She said, however, that one time when one of her little girls died, her father “took her and laid the fence down and went through that way some way” but that there was no road that she saw. She further said that the public did not use any road through this land during the fourteen years she lived there. Her husband corroborated her testimony in saying that the fence was still there in 1933 and that there were no gates or bars until after he left. He said that the only time any of the public went through this land was when walking or hunting.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit