Mississippi Supreme Court November 6, 1950, No. 37589 (Bradley v. Gulf States Creosoting Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-11-1950
Alexander, J.
Bradley brought an action for the price of poles ordered by appellee. The defendant by successive pleadings set *749up want of title in Bradley to some of the poles, the commingling therewith of other poles, and failure of specifications.
The appellee had accepted and paid for several car loads of poles, but upon receipt of an anonymous communication warning that some were being cut from Sixteenth Section lands it refused further' deliveries. Whereupon, Bradley salvaged part of the poles by resale and after crediting the proceeds, sued for the balance due. He appeals from a verdict and judgment for the defendant and assigns for error the exclusion of certain evidence and the granting of instructions.
We find no error in the admission or exclusion of evidence except as to the refusal to allow the plaintiff to introduce an order of the board of supervisors authorizing a timber deed to him. It may have been unnecessary for the plaintiff to show title by his testimony in chief but the exhibit was at least relevant.
The instructions deal chiefly with the status of plaintiff’s title. He had an agricultural lease to Sixteenth Section school lands and some of the poles were cut therefrom. When his title was questioned, he procured a timber deed from the board of supervisors dated July 17, 1948. No authority is shown for cutting timber from the school lands prior thereto and the instructions so informing the jury were correct.
An instruction for the defendant directing the jury to disregard the agricultural lease was improper. While the lease of itself conferred no right to cut and sell the timber, it was relevant as showing the preferred status of Bradley with respect to the granting of a timber deed.
The court was in error in charging that the burden of proof as to title was upon the plaintiff. This was the substance of the affirmative pleas filed by the defendant. 16 Am. Jur., Deeds, Section 372; 46 id., Sales, Sections 407, 409.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit