Tennessee Supreme Court February 10, 1950 (Whedbee v. Godsey)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-02-1950

Mr. Justice Prewitt

delivered the opinion of the Court.

The Chancellor sustained a demurrer to the original bill, as amended, and held valid Chapter 176, Private Acts of 1945, creating a Sanitary District of Fountain City in Knox County.

The bill assails the constitutionality of Chapter 176, Private Acts of 1945, as amended by Chapter 143, Private Acts of 1947, and by Chapter 831, Private Acts of 1949.

*143By amendment, the bill also challenges the validity of Chapter 126, Public Acts of 1943, because complainants claim that the first three Acts are in violation of Article 2, Section 17, of the Constitution, as said original Act, as amended, embraces more than one subject.

Complainants contend that the above-mentioned Acts run contrary to the terms of Chapter 248, Public Acts of 1937, known as “The Utility District Act of 1937,” which is a general Act applicable to any portion of any county in the State seeking to create a sewer and water system.

As to the constitutionality of Chapter 176, Private Acts of 1945, and the amendments thereto (which amendments carry the exact wording of the original Act), the caption is as follows: “An Act to incorporate the Sanitary District of Fountain City in the County of Knox, and to prescribe its duties and powers, and provide for the election of officers and prescribe their duties.”

The first portion of the caption of Chapter 176, Private Acts of 1945, above quoted, provides for a plan of incorporation of the Fountain City area to create a sanitary district. The caption has but one purpose, and that is, sanitation, which includes waterworks, water supplies, distribution, sewerage, and other utilities that are necessary to reach the object intended by the Act. The body of the Act is within the caption and the title gives sufficient notice of the contents of the Act. This being true, these Acts do not, therefore, run counter to Article 2, Section 17, of the Constitution.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.