Tennessee Supreme Court June 9, 1950 (Cartwright v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-06-1950

Mr. Justice Tomlinson

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This is an appeal from a conviction of unlawfully possessing whiskey with punishment fixed at a fine of $100 and a suspended jail sentence of six months. Reversal is sought on the theory that the finding of this whiskey in Cartwright’s home was the result of an unlawful search.

A constable of Bradley County, introduced as a witness for the State, testified that on a specified date he received a complaint that defendant was at his home in Cleveland "drunk and disturbing the neighbors”. He took no action in response to this complaint and received the same complaint on the next day. Thereupon, in company with another officer they proceeded to the home of Cartwright and took their position in the public road at a place which concealed them from the view of Cart-*545wrigilt’s home. This witness then heard “loud, drunken talk and cursing come from defendant’s house”. He and his companion officer thereupon entered without knocking and found the defendant and one Herb Flowers in the room drunk. Thereupon, “I looked in the back or South part of the room, and there I found . . .”.

At this point Cartwright’s attorney objected to any evidence as to what this witness found in the house, the objection being on the ground that the entry and search was unlawful. In the absence of the jury this witness repeated in response to the query of the Court that while he and his fellow officer were standing in the public road he “could hear cursing and loud talk” coming from this residence. Thereupon, the Court admitted this evidence over the objection and exception of Cartwright’s attorney.

The testimony of the witness before the jury then continued as follows: “I proceeded into the back part of the room, and there I found an empty gallon jug: I looked into a paper sack which was sitting by the empty jug, and there I found a gallon jug that was nearly full of white whiskey. It looked like about a pint short of 'a full gallon. ...

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.