District Court, W.D. Louisiana September 18, 1950, Civ. A. No. 2949 (Mason v. Salter)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-09-1950
DAWKINS, Chief Judge.
Plaintiff sues on an alleged “verbal agreement” for a balance of $6,093.61, claimed to be due him for work done in making “certain alterations and additions to defendant’s residence * * The complaint states that he is “a resident and citizen of the County of Hidalgo, State of Texas.”
Defendant, a citizen of Louisiana, according to the pleading, has moved to dis*628miss on the grounds that when complainant “executed the affidavit attached to his complaint on March 17, 1950, he was a resident of the City of Shreveport, and had been for many years prior thereto,” and further “that the amount in controversy is actually less than $3000,” or below the jurisdiction of this court.
Á stipulation was filed in which it was agreed that:
1) On March 17, 1950, when plaintiff signed the affidavit supporting his petition, he “was still a resident of the City of Shreveport, • Louisiana”;
2) He “did, however, go to Texas immediately thereafter and was in Texas on March 20, 1950, when this suit was filed, and has remained in the State of Texas as a resident thereof * * * to the present date”; and
3) Defendant had paid “various subcontractors on this contract” the total sum of $1,771.25.
There was no further proof by either side. The verification of the complaint was, as stated, on March 17, 1950.
Taking the issues as to jurisdiction in reverse order, it is sufficient to say that, in so far as the amount is concerned, the complaint alleges a balance due for labor, etc., the defendant having furnished the materials, in the sum of more than $6,000, while the stipulation concedes this should be reduced by approximately $1,700, which would still leave the demand considerably in excess of $3,000. In the absence of any further proof to the contrary,' the jurisdictional amount appears to be sufficiently established, and the motion to dismiss to that extent will be denied.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit