Court of Appeals of Texas November 21, 1951, 12288 (Timon v. Dolan)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-11-1951
POPE, Justice.
This is an appeal from an order of the District Court permanently enjoining Mrs. Laura Timón Dolan, the appellee, from certain conduct. . No statement of facts has been brought forward, but the court has made and filed findings of fact and conclusions of law.
Mrs. Bessie Timón, the wife of Walter F. Timón, commenced suit against Mrs. Laura Timón Dolan, a widow. She is the sister of Walter F. Timón. Mrs. Timón asked that the sister be enjoined from corning about the hospital or home, or other place where Mjr. Timón was confined during his sickness, and also that she be enjoined from talking to, addressing, attacking, molesting, or in any way interfering with the rightful activities of the wife. After trial and hearing, the court in accord with appellant’s prayer, enjoined the sister from “in any manner talking to, addressing, attacking, molesting or in any way interfering with the rightful activities of the plaintiff, Mrs. Bessie Timón, and in particular with respect to the right of this "plaintiff to visit her husband, Walter F. Timón, at all times in Spohn Hospital, * * The court modified the other relief sought, by also permitting the sister to visit with Walter Timón for one hour each day between four and five in the afternoon.
An analysis of the appellant’s prayer and the relief granted causes wonderment as to why she appealed from the court’s order. What was sought was substantially granted. Appellee, who is under the restraint, has not complained of the injunction. .The minor modification of the relief sought, wherein the sister was granted the limited designated time for visitation, is not challenged by any one. But in the development of the proceedings leading up to the hearing and the injunction, an incidental procedural skirmish has almost obscured the object of the suit and even the victory appellant won but has appealed from.
Mrs. Timón originally instituted suit without joining her husband.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit