Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit August 20, 1951, 10387_1 (In Re Solar Mfg. Corp. (Two Cases))
Also known as
United States · · · 20-08-1951
GOODRICH, Circuit Judge.
These appeals raise objections to two orders entered by the District Court in proceedings involving reorganization of the Solar Manufacturing Company. One order appealed from is that of the district judge refusing to order the reduction of the number of trustees from two to one. The other appeal raises objections to the granting of interim allowances to the trustees and their counsel.
We start with the undisputed premise that the matters in question are for the discretion of the district judge.
1
Such discretion is particularly appropriate in this type of case which necessarily involves passing upon ever so many administrative matters in the course of a reorganization proceeding. No appellate court with the paper record before it, even though advised by the most eloquent of counsel, can have the feel of a case as the judge who ha3 lived with it from week to week and month to month.
On December 28, 1950 the district judge made allowances to the two trustees of $8,000 each. These interim allowances covered a period from December 1, 1949 to November 24, 1950. Prior to that, in December, 1949, there had been an allowance of $25,000 ($12,500 to each). The district court also made an interim allowance to counsel of $15,000. Counsel had not received any allowance prior to this for he was appointed only on November 16, 1949.
If we were to exercise judgment in the first instance it is likely that we should have made the allowance to counsel and
*274
not to the trastees. Counsel did a great deal of work during the year 1950 and he should not be compelled to wait too long before receiving some payment for it.
The trustees, on the other hand, ceased to run a business when the plant properties of Solar were sold. Their task became thereupon much simpler. It was to process claims, make payments of assets as ordered by the court and advise counsel concerning certain important litigation now instituted.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit