Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit December 3, 1951, 6277_1 (Oxford Boatyard Co. v. Warman)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-12-1951

PER CURIAM.

This is an appeal from a judgment for plaintiff in an action for breach of warranty in the construction and sale of a small sailing boat. The case was heard without a jury by the trial judge, who found that there was breach of the warranty relied on and gave judgment for plaintiff, the purchaser of the boat, in the sum of $3240.51 with interest. The warranty relied on was that the “highest grade equipment, materials and workmanship” should be used in the building of the boat, and the judge found that in the construction of the decks no paint or other protective substance was used, as should have been done, to protect the canvas covering or coamings between joints, with the result that water seeped in and caused rotting

*639

of beams and plywood. He found also that the screws used in fastening the deck were not of the highest quality, as they should have been under the warranty. The defendant contends that the boat was in all respects properly constructed and that the rotting of the beams and plywood was due to the failure of plaintiffs to keep it properly painted, that the screws complained of were of the best quality and of the sort customarily used for the purpose involved, that the damages were not properly established and that timely notice of intention to claim damages had not been given as required by the Uniform Sales Act, Annotated Code of Maryland Art. 83, Sec. 67.

The evidence as to whether the boat was properly constructed with repect to the use of paint or other protective substance on the canvas at joints or coamings is conflicting, as is also the evidence as to whether the screws used were in accordance with the -warranty. No purpose would be served by setting forth this evidence at length. It is sufficient to say that it amply supports the findings of the trial judge both that there was a breach of the warranty and that the breach was the cause of the damage of which plaintiff complains.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.