District Court, W.D. Louisiana October 23, 1951, Civ. A. 2911 (Clark v. Gifford-Hill & Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-10-1951
DAWKINS, Chief Justice.
This case was tried to a jury on a claim for damages arising from the pollution of Turkey Creek, caused by the defendant in its gravel operations. There was a verdict in the plaintiffs favor in the sum of $1500. The matter is now before the court on the prayer of the same complaint for an injunction against further pollution.
Since the application for the writ was submitted to the Judge on the record made up in the trial of the claim for damages, defendant has asked to have the case reopened for the purpose of considering' evidence of a change of conditions which it claims has removed the danger of further pollution. The court suggested that the evidence be taken as to such changes before the motion to re-open was heard by the court, without prejudice, to be considered if the court concluded it should do so in finally determining the rights to such writ. The matter was again argued and submitted, first, as to whether the case should be reopened, and, if so, as to the effects of this new evidence.
After due consideration, the court is of the view that the case should be reopened and this evidence considered. The record, as thus added to, established the following facts: At the time this suit was filed and for a considerable period prior thereto, defendant had been digging or mining gravel in a certain area of its property, consisting of approximately • one hundred acres, which were so situated that large areas of lands and small streams drained and flowed into its gravel pit by gravity, which caused a continued increase of muddy water as more space was provided in removing the top soil and the gravel. This lake in some places was dug to such depths that it has formed a deep body of water which is still muddy from the wash of its gravel and the inability of the water to escape because of the levee.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit