Superior Court of Pennsylvania January 17, 1952, Appeal, 160 (Commonwealth v. Brewer)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-01-1952
Opinion by
Hirt, J.,
Appellant Henry Brewer pleaded guilty in open court, with a co-defendant, to three separate charges of armed robbery. His pleas were endorsed on each of the indictments and were signed by him. As of May 10, 1946, he was sentenced on each of the three bills to a term of imprisonment of from 2 to 6 years in the Western Penitentiary to be served consecutively; he concedes that the sentences on two of the bills, Nos. 21 and 25 May Sessions 1946, were proper.
1
On June 7, 1951 he presented his petition for a writ of coram nobis, seeking to have the sentence on bill 24, May Sessions 1946, set aside on the ground that the indictment did not charge armed robbery and no robbery was in fact committed. Under the circumstances the lower court, by order entered by the sentencing judge, properly refused the writ.
The ancient remedy of error coram nobis is still in existence in Pennsylvania.
Fisher v. Railway Co.,
185 Pa. 602, 40 A. 97. But the writ is an extraordinary remedy rarely invoked (Cf.
Commonwealth v. Harris,
351 Pa. 325, 329, 41 A. 2d 688) and one which in practice has become almost obsolete because of the more convenient remedies by motion and, in criminal cases, also by petition for habeas corpus when a final judgment of sentence is sought to be set aside on the ground that it was unlawfully imposed. At eommon law the remedy of coram nobis was used
to correct errors of fact unknown at the time of - trial to both the party seeking relief and to the court.
Under the writ' in an
*253
appropriate case a judgment can be set aside by the court which entered it, for material errors of fact,
but not of law,
affecting its validity, and unknown to the court when it was entered.
Howard v. State,
58 Ark. 229, 24 S. W. 8;
Smulski v. H. Feinberg Furniture Co.,
38 Del. 451, 193 A. 585. Accordingly, where such errors of fact are made to appear the remedy ordinarily will not be denied because of the mere lapse of time.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit