Appellate Court of Illinois January 22, 1952, Gen. 45,453 (Espinoza v. Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-01-1952
Mr. Presiding Justice Tuohy
delivered the opinion of the court.
Plaintiffs, as beneficiaries, each filed suit on a $2,000 certificate of insurance issued by the defendant in favor of each of their husbands, Pedro Espinoza and Esteban Martinez. The cases, consolidated below, were tried before a jury, resulting in verdicts in favor of both plaintiffs for the face amount of each certificate plus interest. Motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdicts was allowed, and for a new trial denied.
Insured decedents had been friends for a number of years, having been schoolboys together in Texas, and were employed by the same company in Chicago. At the time of their deaths, Pedro was twenty-three and Esteban twenty years of age. On the night of their deaths October 28, 1945 they had done considerable drinking of alcoholic beverages over a period of five or six hours at taverns in the vicinity of Hals ted and Madison streets in Chicago, Illinois. Sometime around 11:45 p.m. they left a tavern known as the Monterey Bar, after a quarrel, went to the street outside, each drew a revolver and each shot and killed the other.
Plaintiffs maintain that under the evidence a question of fact is presented as to whether or not the deaths were accidental within the terms of the insurance policies. The pertinent provisions of each policy of insurance provided (a) that there may be no recovery unless the insured’s death is caused directly and exclusively by external, violent and purely accidental means; (b) that there may be no recovery where the insured’s death was caused directly or indirectly, wholly or partly, by “participation in or consequence of having participated in the committing of a felony”; (c) that there must be submitted to the defendant company as a condition precedent to recovery, within 90 days of the insured’s death, due proof that said death was caused ‘ ‘ directly and exclusively by external, violent and purely accidental means.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit