Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit May 10, 1952, 13927 (City of Fort Lauderdale v. Freeman)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-05-1952

HUTCHESON, Chief Judge.

Aggrieved at an order

1

of the district judge, which had affirmed the order of the referee deferring action on the city’s petition and continuing the trustee in possession, the City, appealing on a statement of points and .a limited record, is here insisting that the order appealed from was erroneously entered and must be reversed.

The trustee, pointing out that the orders of referee and judge were not final but interlocutory, indeed were not in a legal sense dispositive, insists: (1) that the referee’s order

2

was not reviewable

3

by the judge; and (2) that the judge’s order was not appealable.

In addition, insisting that the appeal should be dismissed as moot, it attaches to its motion an order

4

of the referee dated Feb. 29, 1952, ordering the trustee to liquidate the assets of the bankrupt and to abandon and vacate the premises occupied by him.

In support of its second point, appellee, pointing to the nature of the relief sought by appellant and canvassing the cases dealing with the distinction between a proceeding in bankruptcy and a controversy arising in a proceeding in bank

*124

ruptcy,

5

and to the rule that appeals from interlocutory orders in bankruptcy which are trivial in their effect on the proceedings may be refused,

6

relies strongly on our case of Universal Oil Products v. Cosden Petroleum Corp., 5 Cir., 178 F.2d 495, construing 11 U.S.C.A. § 47.

Appellant, with a display of learning and a wealth of citation deserving of a better and stronger cause, attacks appellee’s claim, that the order appealed from was entered in a controversy arising in a proceeding in bankruptcy.

Insisting that it was entered in a proceeding in bankruptcy and marshalling its cases ■in support, it urges upon us, in.addition, that if this is not so, this court would still have jurisdiction under Sec. 1292(1), Title 28, because the appeal was in part from an order refusing to dissolve or modify an injunction.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.