Supreme Court of Arkansas May 19, 1952, 4-9812 (Clement v. Blythe)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-05-1952
George Rose Smith,’ J.
This is a controversy between W. R. Blythe’s three daughters and his one son with reference to the division of the 310 acres that Blythe owned at his death intestate in 1932. Blythe’s widow died in 1948, and after her death this partition suit was brought. The only disputed issue is whether an additional 75 acres, which Blythe conveyed to his son, the appellee, in 1930, should be treated as an advancement and considered as part of the estate in the partition. The chancellor, holding that the 1930 conveyance was not an advancement, awarded the appellee a one-fourth interest in the 310 acres without regard to the fact that he had received the 75-acre tract during his father’s lifetime.
In 1929 Blythe and his wife were living alone in Faulkner Comity, the four children having married and moved away. In December of that year Blythe proposed to his son that if the latter and his wife would come back and live in the vicinity of his parents they would convey to the son the 75-acre tract. The appellee accepted this offer, gave up his job in Pulaski County, and went back to Faulkner County. Mr. and Mrs. Blythe then conveyed the tract to their son, the deed reciting that the son should live with and take care of his parents for the rest of their lives, else the deed would be void. The appellee lived in the family home until 1934, when he built a house on the 75-acre tract. This land is only a few hundred yards from the homestead and was occupied by the appellee until his mother’s death in 1948. Neither parent is shown to have complained that their son failed to carry out his bargain in any respect, and the appellants do not ask that the 1930 deed be canceled on the theory that the appellee should have done more for his parents than he did.
To this point the testimony does not show an advancement.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit