Connecticut Superior Court June 9, 1952, File 84972 (Schwartz v. Kelley)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-06-1952

Mellitz, J.

This is a suit to restrain the defendants who compose the liquor control commission of the state of Connecticut, from enforcing the provisions of §§ 904b-907b of the 1951 Supplement to the General Statutes, enacted as Public Act No. 200 at the 1951 session of the General Assembly. The plaintiffs are permittees engaged in the retail sale of packaged alcoholic liquors for off-premises consumption under liquor package store permits issued by the liquor control commission. In general, the act requires, as a prerequisite to the sale of branded or labeled packaged alcoholic liquors by out-of-state shippers, manufacturers or wholesaler permittees that they file a schedule of minimum consumer resale prices with the liquor control commission and that the prices filed shall be uniform throughout the state. Eetail permittees are prohibited, under penalties provided in the act, from selling at less than the scheduled 'minimum consumer resale price then in effect.

*61

The plaintiffs attack the validity of the act on the ground that the price-fixing power lodged in segments of the liquor industry is an illegal delegation of legislative power, and that it violates the Sherman Anti-Trust Act and the due process and equal protection clauses of the constitution of the state of Connecticut and that of the United States.

The law is designed to regulate and control the distribution and sale of alcoholic liquor. The propriety of legislation to that end, in the exercise of the police power of the state has long been recognized, and is not questioned. Since the twenty-first amendment to the United States constitution, a state may absolutely prohibit the manufacture, transportation, sale or possession of intoxicants. It has a “large discretion as to the means employed to protect its citizens against the evil incident to the liquor traffic .... The business being one which admittedly may be dangerous to public health, safety and morals . . .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.