Alabama Court of Appeals October 7, 1952, 3 Div. 938 (Roberson Motor Co. v. Heath)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-10-1952
HARWOOD, Judge.
As submitted to the jury the complaint in this cause contained three counts, one count being in trespass for the wrongful taking of two automobiles, another count in trover for conversion of the automobiles, and a third count for malicious prosecution. All counts claimed damages of $10,000.
Issue was joined on the defendant’s plea in short by consent, filed separately and severally as to each count.
The jury returned a general verdict in favor of the plaintiff, and assessed damages at $1,000, and judgment was entered accordingly. '
Defendant’s motion for a new trial being timely filed and overruled an appeal was perfected to this court.
The appeal is here upon the record proper, there being no transcription of the evidence contained therein.
Appellant has made two assignments of error. Both relate to the same point, namely, that error resulted from the lower court’s oral charge as it related to damages to be awarded in event the jury should find for the plaintiff.
In this connection the record shows the following:
“You take the case and after carefully considering the case here, if you find that under Count 3 that the cars were wrongfully taken from him, or under Count 4 that they were converted in violation of his rights, or under Count 5 that a case was prosecuted against him without probable cause, then you write your verdict, we the jury find for the plaintiff and assess his damages at so many dollars, not exceeding the amount claimed in the complaint.
*580"On the other hand, after careful consideration of all the evidence and ■facts if it does not reasonably satisfy ■you that the charges set out in this complaint by the plaintiff are true, that these cars were wrongfully taken from him, that the case of prosecution was without basis, then you would write your verdict, we the jury find for the defendants.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit