Louisiana Court of Appeal November 3, 1952, No. 19702 (Daniel v. New Orleans Public Service, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-11-1952
McBRIDE, Judge.
Plaintiff-appellant, whose suit was dismissed below, claims of defendant $2,937, alleging that his automobile -was run into by a passenger bus owned by defendant, and operated 'by one of its employees. The amount claimed represents the value of plaintiff’s Ford automobile, which is alleged to have -been demolished, and for damages for personal injuries, with attendant expenses, alleged to have been sustained by plaintiff. ■
The accident occurred on the morning of March 2, 19S0, at Esplanade Avenue and North Rampart Street, in the intersection formed by the lane on North Rampart Street reserved for traffic moving downtown, and the lane on Esplanade Avenue which accommodates traffic going towards the river. The bus, which was traveling towards the river on Esplanade Avenue, after making a passenger stop at the'lake side of North Rampart Street, proceeded forward into North Rampart Street at a rate of speed which does not appear from the record. Plaintiff charges the bus operator, among other enumerated acts alleged to constitute negligence, with 'having entered North Rampart Street in the face of a red or unfavorable traffic light. There is irreconcilable conflict in the testimony in the two camps of witnesses as to whether the bus started into the intersection on the red light, but the trial judge resolved the question in accord with plaintiff’s contention, and held as a fact that the bus operator did violate the traffic signal. In view of the conflict in the testimony, we can but invoke the oft-repeated and time-honored rule that a finding of fact by the trial judge, where the evidence is conflicting and a question of veracity is involved, should not be disturbed unless manifestly erronéous. We find no such error.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit