Montana Supreme Court May 20, 1952, No. 9062 (Alexander & Hollenbeck v. Flage)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-05-1952

MR. JUSTICE METCALF:

In this action the plaintiff seeks to nullify the 1949 assessment of real property in Rosebud county, Montana. The pertinent *44allegation of the complaint raising the question is: “ The plaintiff alleges that the taxes for the year 1949 amounting to the sum of $3,217.84 were unlawful and invalid and illegally levied for the reason that said taxes were not a levy of the duly elected, acting and constituted assessor of Rosebud County, Montana, but were in their legal effect a levy by a separate entity employed by the county commissioners of Rosebud County, Montana, without any request or requisition having been made to said board by the duly elected, acting and constituted assessor of Rosebud County, Montana.”

The plaintiff’s prayer asked for a refund of taxes in the amount of $1,587.23, which is the difference between the amount paid in 1948 and the amount allegedly illegally assessed in 1949. The plaintiff contends that the 1948 assessment was a fair valuation and continued to be a fair valuation in 1949.

On October 4, 1948, the board of county commissioners of Rosebud county entered into an agreement with a firm of Missoula, Montana, doing business under the name of Professional Account Service, whereby the Professional Account Service was employed to make a general revaluation of the taxable personal property, real estate and improvements of Rosebud county. The Professional Account Service made the revaluation and submitted it to the board of county commissioners and the assessor.

It is the plaintiff’s contention that the report and revaluation was submitted to the board of county commissioners; that board in turn ordered the Rosebud county assessor to accept the report as his new appraisement and basis for assessment; and that the county assessor did so accept the report and failed to exercise any independent power but acted solely under the instructions given him by the board of county commissioners.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.