United States Court of Military Appeals August 14, 1952, No. 613 (United States v. West)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-08-1952
Opinion of the Court
Paul W. Brosman, Judge:
The accused in this case was tried by general court-martial on October 16, 1951, at Fort Hood, Texas, for desertion with intent to remain absent permanently, in violation of Article of War 58, 10 USC § 1530. He was found guilty as charged. The findings, and sentence were approved by the convening authority, and affirmed without opinion by a board of review in the office of The Judge Advocate General, United States Army. On May 19, 1952, we granted the accused’s petition for review. Two assignments of error have been made: (1) That the evidence is insufficient as a matter of law to support the court-martial’s findings of guilty of desertion; and (2) That the court-martial erred to the substantial prejudice of the accused in its post-finding consideration of two previous convictions.
II
We dispose first and briefly of the contention of insufficiency. We have examined the record and concluded that the first assignment of error is without merit. The evidence shows that the accused absented himself without authority from his organization on May 23, 1951, just before its departure for an overseas assignment, and remained absent until his apprehension in Dallas, Texas, on September 11, 1951. Petitioner took the stand and denied an intention to remain absent permanently. Instead, he stated, he fully intended at all times to return to his unit and to accompany it to its overseas destination. In this connection we recently said in United States v. Ferretti (No. 213), 1 USCMA 323, 3 CMR 57, decided April 18, 1952:
“While the accused denied categorically that he entertained for any *592moment of time an intention to abandon the service permanently, it does not follow that the members of the court-martial were bound to accept this protestation as conclusive proof, or even as evidence strongly tending to exculpate petitioner.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit