United States Court of Military Appeals August 29, 1952, No. 229 (United States v. Kubel)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-08-1952

Opinion of the Court

GEORGE W. Latimee, Judge:

The accused was tried by a general court-martial and found guilty of four offenses, all committed prior to the effective date of the Uniform Code of Military Justice. They consisted of (1) larceny of property of the United States Government in violation of Article of War 94, 10 USC § 1566; (2) unlawful sale of same property in violation of Article of War 84, 10 USC § 1556; and (3) and (4) two absences without proper leave in violation of Article of War 61, 10 USC § 1533. The accused was found guilty as charged, with certain exceptions and substitutions being made in the findings on the offense of unlawful sale, and he was sentenced to dishonorable discharge, total forfeitures, and confinement at hard labor for ten years. The findings and sentence were approved by the reviewing authority and a board of review in the office- of The Judge Advocate General of the Army affirmed. The accused then petitioned this Court to review the record of his conviction, and his petition was granted on the sole issue of whether he was prejudiced because the law officer failed to include all the necessary elements of larceny (Charge I) in his instructions to the court-martial.

While the issue before this Court is concerned only with questionable, instructions on the larceny offense alleged under Charge I, an intelligent disposition of the ease requires consideration of the instructions given on the unlawful sale (Charge II). The specification of Charge I alleged that on or about April 19, 1951, the accused felo-niously stole 80 blankets, valued at $648.80, property of the United States Government, furnished or intended for the military service. The specification under Charge II alleged that on or about April 19, 1951, the accused unlawfully sold to Kil Yon Ki, a Korean civilian, 80 blankets of the value of $648.80 issued for the use. of the military service of the United States.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.