District Court, N.D. Ohio April 15, 1952, No. 28926 (United States v. Brotherhood of Locomotive Firemen & Enginemen)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-04-1952
FREED, District Judge (oral opinion).
The nature of the judicial inquiry at this stage of the proceedings is limited in its scope. The application for a preliminary injunction is addressed to the discretion of the Court and seeks to maintain the status quo until such time as the cause may be heard on the merits and the rights of the parties finally determined. It imposes upon this Court the duty merely to determine these problems: Does the controversy involve grave and substantial questions of law and fact and does the defendants’ conduct present an immediate threat of irreparable injury to the United States. An examination of the adjudicated cases discloses that the courts have uniformly agreed with this view. It must be clearly understood that the Court is not now called upon to render an ultimate decision as to the Government’s right to a permanent injunction to prevent a strike by the defendants.
The United States Government appeals to this Court to issue a preliminary injunction to prevent the three unions of railroad employees from associating and participating in a strike against the Terminal Railroad Association of St. Louis and that portion of the New York Central rail system *743which runs west of Buffalo, New York. The Government’s complaint is predicated upon Executive Orders Nos. 10141 and 10155 issued by the President on July 8 and August 25 of 1950 respectively. They order the seizure by the United States Government of the operation of a substantial number of the railroads of this country. It is alleged that by virtue of the Executive Orders and the action of the Department of the Army pursuant to the Orders, a strike by the employees of these railroads is a strike against the United States of America.
The defendants challenge the constitutional validity of the seizure orders. The unions deny that seizure as a fact has been accomplished.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit