District Court, E.D. South Carolina June 2, 1952, Civ. No. 3073 (Fidelity & Casualty Co. of New York v. Wilson)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-06-1952

WYCHE, Chief Judge.

This is an action of interpleader brought by Fidelity and -Casualty Company of New York against the principal, the obligee and various claimants on an -Owner’s Protective Bond issued by it as surety in connection with-an apartment house project in Charleston, South Carolina. It was commenced by service -of the Summons and Complaint •on all named defendants, -together with a temporary restraining order issued by -this ‘Court February 4, 1952 restraining all of the -defendants .and others -similarly situated from instituting or prosecuting any suits that might render plaintiff liable on .the bond, and :a Rule to .Show Cause why an -Order to Interplead and a permanent injunction should not be granted.

All of the named defendants with the exception of three have filed responsive pleadings which are in effect Answers on the merits stating claims -against the prime contractor, -the sub-contractor and/or the bonding company, and not objecting to the jurisdiction of the court and the issuance of the Order to Interplead prayed for in the Complaint. Defendants Skinner and Ruddock, Inc. (the prime contractor) and United States Guarantee Company (its bonding company) filed Returns -to the Rule to Show Cause and notice of a Motion to dismiss the Complaint on the ground that this court did not have jurisdiction of the cause of action, -because of the lack .of diversity of citizenship and adversity of cl-aims. , These were the only responsive pleadings objecting to the' Order to Inter-plead and the jurisdiction of the Court. In accordance with a stipulation between counsel, defendant Edwin M. -Gill, U. S. Collector of' Internal Revenue for the District of North Carolina, has not yet filed any responsive pleading, pending determination by the proper officials of the action •to be taken on behalf of -the United States.

The Rule to Show Cause and the Motion to Dismiss were argued before me by counsel on March 17, 1952, and briefs filed by the interested parties.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.