District Court, District of Columbia June 25, 1952, Cr. No. 579-52 (United States v. Peckham)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-06-1952
HOLTZOFF, District Judge.
The defendant, Henry L. Peckham, Jr., a physician, was indicted on two charges of committing an abortion. The indictment consists of two counts; the first count charging an abortion committed on May 2, 1951, and the second count charging an abortion committed on January 18, 1952. The same female was involved in both counts.
The jury found the defendant guilty on the first count, and not guilty on the second count. The defendant now moves for a new trial. While the motion sets forth thirty-three grounds for the relief prayed for, the various grounds can be grouped into a few classifications, especially as many of them are more or less repetitious.
One of the objections raised on this motion is that during the cross-examination of Dr. Kilpatrick, of Mount Alto Hospital, *776the Court did not permit all of the records of the Hospital relating to the victim of the abortions to be disclosed to defense counsel. Dr. Kilpatrick was asked by Government counsel on direct examination as to what was the cause of the condition of the victim when she was brought to Mount Alto Hospital.. Dr. Kilpatrick expressed the opinion that she was suffering from peritonitis secondary to an induced abortion. The Court directed Dr. Kilpatrick to disclose all those portions of the Hospital files which he used in reaching his conclusion. The Court excluded all other portions of the record as not being relevant and as being confidential because no one had waived the privilege of the patient. The Court particularly excluded any entries in those records relating to prior abortions which the witness had suffered, on the ground that those matters were absolutely irrelevant and could play no part in the case except to embarrass the patient, to whom the records related. In any event, Dr. Kilpatrick’s testimony related to the second count of the indictment, on which the defendant was eventually acquitted. Consequently, the alleged error as to those records has become moot.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit