District Court, N.D. California July 9, 1952, No. 25940 (Hertz v. Consolidated Fisheries, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-07-1952

HARRIS, District Judge.

Libelant, owner and pilot of a 36-foot gas screw called the Diana Claire, seeks to recover damages from respondents, owners of a 55.8-foot fishing vessel called the Crescent which caused the sinking of the Diana Claire in a collision at sea.

During the trial, the parties agreed upon certain facts: The collision took place on a clear, windless day upon a calm sea. Both vessels were navigating on the high seas outside the Golden Gate and were subject to the regulations set forth in the International Rules of Navigation, 33 U.S.C.A. §§ 61-141.

The Diana Claire was traveling at about 8 knots and was unencumbered. The Crescent was making about 2 knots and was encumbered with a dragline pulling about 5,0C0 pounds, plus the weight of the fish in the net.

The Diana Claire was moving in a southeasterly direction and the Crescent was navigating in a westerly direction as the vessels approached on crossing courses. *949The angle of the convergence was from 40° to 45°, with the Diana Claire on the starboard side of the Crescent before the collision and the Crescent off the port bow of the Diana Claire. The Diana Claire was navigating through an automatic pilot and never changed course prior to the collision.

The Captain of the Crescent reversed his vessel when the two boats were within 100 feet or less of one another. He did not change course. He first noted or heeded the Diana Claire when the two boats were a maximum of 200 yards apart.

The impact between the vessels caused no appreciable damage to the Crescent. It made a hole in the Diana Claire which permitted water to enter rapidly until the vessel sank.

The parties dispute certain other facts. For example, the libelant testified that he placed the Diana Claire’s engines in reverse shortly before the collision but did not succeed in taking the way off the vessel in time to avoid the collision. The Captain of the Crescent refused to' admit that libelant made any effort to place the boat in reverse.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.