District Court, D. Delaware December 30, 1952, No. 1671 (Texas Co. v. Lea River Lines, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-1952

LEAHY, Chief Jüdge.

1. Respondent, Lea River Lines, Inc., was the owner of the tug Tadpole..

2. On June 6, 1949, at Lockpo.rt, Illinois, respondent was given the exclusive handling, care and custody of a cargo of Fire Chief gasoline laden aboard the Barge LRL 104.

3. Libellant, the Texas Company, was the owner of the cargo laden aboard the Barge LRL 104 on June 6, 1949. ;

4. At'about 9:30 a. .m. June 6, 1949, and after the libellant’s cargo of gasoline had been laden aboard the barge ’ LRL 104, respondent discovered that part of the cargo was leaking from the starboard No. 3 compartment of the barge LRL 104.

5. The leak in the starboard No. 3 ■compartment of the LRL 104 had resulted from respondent’s towboat Tadpole, while turning the barge LRL 104 at Lockport, Illinois, on June '6, 1949, previous to loading, negligently allowing the barge to come into contact with the concrete wall of the canal.

When an accident occurs, under circumstances in which it would not ordinarily have occurred had' the proper care been exercised, duty is on the tug of proving proper care.1 There arises a presumption of negligence where there is no reasonable explanation of collision.2 There is a duty to disclose what happened, what was done to avoid, and what would have been necessary to prevent the damage to the vessel.3

Conclusions of Law.

1. The loss of part of libellant’s cargo of Fire Chief gasoline was due to the negligent damaging of the barge LRL 104 by the towboat Tadpole at Lockport, Illinois, on June 6, 1949.

2. Respondent argues it was a mere bailee — not' a tower — and as such it was free to enter into a contract limiting itself as to liability as a bailee for hire. Respondent’s argument that the agreement between Texas and Lee exonerated the latter from liability for the loss of cargo is rejected.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.