District Court, N.D. New York December 2, 1952, Civ. No. 3841 (Consolidated Car Heating Co. v. Chrome-Gold Alloys Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-12-1952

BRENNAN, Chief Judge.

This is the usual patent infringement action with the usual prayer for relief.

The answer denies the validity and infringement of the patent in suit. The answer of Chrome-Gold Alloys Sales, Inc., also alleges as a counterclaim a cause of action against the plaintiff based upon unfair competition, which is denied in plaintiff’s reply. No evidence was offered on the trial to support the allegations of the counterclaim. It is deemed abandoned and is dismissed for failure of proof.

The plaintiff is a corporation having an office for the transaction of business at Albany, New York, and is the owner of United States Patent No. 2,072,911, issued March 9, 1937, and referred to throughout the trial as the “Touceda” patent. As far as pertinent here its activities involve the manufacture and sale of an alloy known as “Ticonium”, the principal use of which is in the field of dentistry, and particularly in the casting and manufacture of dentures. The product manufactured under the Touceda patent has been used by the public about sixteen years, and the plaintiff has granted some two hundred fifty licenses for the use of the patent. The patent in suit has never before been questioned, although the product is subject to business competition.

Defendant Chrome-Gold Alloys, Inc., is a corporation organized about 1948. It is engaged in the manufacture of the alleged infringing product at Averill Park, New York, with an office at Albany, New York. Defendant Chrome-Gold Alloys Sales, Inc., is a corporation organized in 1950. It has an exclusive sales agreement whereby it sells the product of the co-defendant, and it occupies an office with the manufacturing company at Albany, New York. Two individuals are officers of both companies. The defendants manufacture and sell an alloy known as “Chrome-Gold”. Its principal use is as a casting alloy in the manufacture of dentures and is, therefore, in direct competition with the plaintiff’s product Ticonium.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.