Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court November 9, 1953 (Commonwealth v. Theberge)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-11-1953

Honan, J.

The defendant was indicted, tried, and convicted upon two indictments, the first charging her with manslaughter in two counts, and the second accusing her of arson. Both indictments were tried together subject to G. L. (Ter. Ed.) c. 278, §§ 33A-33G, as amended. The cases are here upon .an appeal with a transcript of the

*522

evidence, a summary of the record, a transcript of the proceedings before the judge in the investigation of a juror, and an assignment of errors.

The defendant with her four children, whose ages ranged from a year and one half to less than eleven years, occupied a tenement, comprising one half of the second floor of a six tenement house. She left these children in the care of the oldest child when she went from her home on the evening of April 3, 1953, accompanied by one Francis. After visiting various drinking resorts, she and Francis returned to her home shortly before midnight. They continued to drink intoxicating liquor which Francis had purchased. They engaged in an argument which awoke the downstairs tenant. Francis left at about three-thirty o’clock in the morning. The defendant requested her son Thomas to give her the keys to the cellar and, when he was unable to find them, she struck him, knocking his head against a pipe. She told him to go up to a tenement on the third floor which was vacant and open the rear window and the front door, which he did. A family named Morasse occupied the other tenement on the top or third floor. The0 Morasse dog began to bark. It does not appear that anything else was done on this floor. When her son returned from the third floor she asked him if he wanted to light a fire. He replied in the negative. She told him he was going to and to come with her. She told him to get an oil lamp. The lamp contained oil and had been used in the' tenement when the supply of electricity failed. The son went with her to a shed or enclosure by or under the rear stairs on the first floor.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.