Supreme Court of Colorado May 18, 1953, No. 16,998 (Thomas v. Blevins)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-05-1953

Mr. Chief Justice Stone

delivered the opinion of the court.

Polly Blevins brought action against A. R. Thomas under the Federal Housing and Rent Act to recover for alleged overcharges of rent. It is not disputed that the leased premises were subject to a rent ceiling of $30 per month, and that the rental charge was $60 per month. The court found in favor of plaintiff tenant, and defendant landlord contends here, as in the trial court, that the leased premises were not subject to the provisions of the housing and rent act.

The rented property consisted of one unit in a four-unit building which formerly had been leased for residence purposes. It consisted of hallway and four rooms appropriately labeled as living room, dining room, bedroom, kitchen and bath, and furnished by the landlord only with kitchen range. In the printed form of lease, as executed by the parties, it was recited that plaintiff was to occupy the same as “sales room and dress shop.” It is disclosed by the evidence that plaintiff furnished the front room with a rug and two-piece living room set and used it as a living room as well as for display of a few dresses, while the former dining room was used for storage, both of personal belongings and of boxes pertaining to her business; that the former bedroom, which was at least as large as the living room, contained her bed and chairs, as well as her sewing machine and pressing board, and was used both as sleeping quarters and in connection with garment alteration and pressing, and that the kitchen was used exclusively for cooking and dining purposes. The apartment was plaintiffs only home. There was substantial evidence that defendant landlord on several occasions visited the premises and knew the uses to which they were put, without objection.

The rule seems to be undisputed, here, as declared in Woods, Housing Expediter v. Whitehouse, *47983 Fed. Supp.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.