Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit January 28, 1954, 11737_1 (Higgins v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-01-1954

EDGERTON, Circuit Judge.

Appellant was convicted of unlawfully possessing marihuana. 26 U.S.C. § 2593(a), 53 Stat. 281. The drug was seized during a search of his room without a warrant. Seeds were found in a paper bag in a chest of drawers, and cigarettes in the pocket of a coat hanging in a closet. The seeds and cigarettes were introduced in evidence. The present question is whether appellant’s motion to suppress the evidence, on the ground that the search was unlawful, should have been granted. The trial court, sitting without a jury, found that appellant consented to the search.

1

At the hearing on the motion to suppress, a police sergeant testified: “ * * I identified myself to him as a police officer and asked him if I couldn’t talk to him in his room. * * * He stated

*820

that that was all right and asked me to accompany him to his room. * * * I told him then about the information that I had, that I had received from the various sources, and he denied this information, denied that he was engaged in any narcotic drug traffic. I asked him then if I could look around. He stated that I could, was perfectly welcome to look anywhere in his room that I wanted to.” Another policeman gave similar testimony. All this was repeated in substance at the trial. Appellant testified at the trial that the officers arrested him in the street, took him to his room, and searched it without asking or receiving permission.

We assume for present purposes that the officers’ testimony was true and the appellant's false. Even so, we think the record does not support the finding that appellant consented to the search. We think the motion to suppress should have been granted.

Words or acts that would show consent in some circumstances do not show it in others. “Non-resistance to the orders or suggestions of the police is not infrequent * * *; true consent, free of fear or pressure, is not so readily to be found.” Judd v. United States, 89 U.S.App.D.C. 64, 66, 190 F. 2d 649, 651.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.